Dating and Marriage: Are We Promoting Polygamy?

Shocking title, I know.  And so was his statement:

“The polygamist lifestyle begins with polygamist thinking.”

Our friend leading Bible study said.

Sometimes the truth IS shocking and we just don’t realize it.

Think this through with me….

“Polygamy…a form of marriage where a person has more than one spouse at the same time.”

Now this is hard for us to swallow, but since God institutes marriages and not the state, He gets to make the rules.  And here are his rules:

“But I tell you that anyone who divorces his wife, except for marital unfaithfulness, causes her to become an adulteress, and anyone who marries the divorced woman commits adultery.”

Obviously this could spawn deep theological discussion on marriage and divorce, but since there is an epidemic of “no-fault divorce” and I’m no theologian, I’ll keep it simple and just refer to that for discussion’s sake. (We’re not discussing abuse in marriage–different topic.)

In God’s eyes, a couple can’t really get an unbiblical divorce.  They can get the state to give them a piece of paper that says they’re divorced, but He says they’re still married and if they remarry it is….yep, polygamy.  Did you think about that before?

I’ve talked about how the dating system primes us for “disposable” thinking which increases likelihood of divorce. In essence then, doesn’t the dating system promote a thought-life akin to polygamy?

In the modern dating system, we are entitled to be romantically involved with as many people as we want and that is socially acceptable.  We can indulge in a physical and emotional experience meant to be reserved for marriage and then drop it on a dime and move on to the next person.  We can shop, use and borrow with reckless abandon.

BUT…when we get married, that track of thinking ingrained by our previous habits is expected to be instantly destroyed and returned to a monogamous state.

Well, at least that’s what used to be expected of marriage before we began accepting polygamy as a way of life.

Why Christians Should be Appalled at the Dating System

I promised in a recent post that I would write again about why I think Christians should be appalled at the system of dating.  It’s a difficult post.  There are many points and rabbit trails I’m tempted to follow.  Here, though, I’ll try to stick to the one, over-arching problem I see with our current dating system.

What’s it for?

It’s not just that the practice is faulty, though it is, or that other practices don’t have flaws, because they do, it’s our fundamental understanding that is wrong.

Dating came from a practice whose purpose was to find a marriage partner.  That’s the whole point.  How did we arrive, then, at encouraging our young people to date and then acting shocked if they talk of marrying before the age of 25?  We expect our 14 year old to become romantically involved with someone and fully expect that they will NOT get married.  We commit parental schizophrenia!

What’s really normal?

In this process we not only permit but encourage our children to commit adultery-like behavior that will follow them into marriage.  What I mean is that our daughter is somebody’s wife, even when she’s young.  Our son is someone’s husband. As Scripture clearly uses language in describing Christ and the church we get a picture of what is expected on the wedding day–a spotless bride.  That is, at the altar, for centuries, it was fully expected that the two getting married had never been romantically involved with anyone else.  This is normal.  What we have now is brand new, and certainly not normal; it’s just all we know in our short life spans.

Forget the fact that by embracing the dating system we submit our children to larger-than-life temptations, the likes of which we wouldn’t permit ourselves to endure, and waste enormous time and energy that should otherwise be spent preparing them for life and marriage.  They aren’t even supposed to be thinking in the direction of romance until they’re ready to get married.

If you are reading and haven’t given the concept of dating much thought, I challenge you to ask yourself a few questions:

1. What is the purpose for allowing my children to date?

2.  Is that purpose working to better prepare them to be a husband or wife?

3.  Can a mother and father present their daughter at the wedding altar and “give this woman” if they haven’t “kept” her throughout her preparations for becoming a wife?

4.  Does dating allow a person to come wholly to his or her spouse?

You may be interested in the other articles I’ve written on dating and courtship which are listed in the “categories” drop-down menu in the side bar.

Courtship: Preparing Sons

A reader mentioned that she hears a lot about preparing daughters for courtship, but not much about sons.  While we haven’t yet walked through courtship, we desire, even now, to prepare both our sons and daughters for the monumental event of marriage.

I think it is worth noting, though it seems like stating the obvious, that a serious decision like marriage should warrant years of preparation.   Most often in our culture, we seem to miss this.  We think that kids can (and deserve) to just have fun during their teen years, with little responsibility and even less preparation for their adult lives.

Is it little wonder, then, why so many couples struggle to even stay together?  Much less flourish in marriage.  Good marriages don’t just happen.  And as parents, we have a grave responsibility to help prepare our children for the next phase of their lives.

These are random thought my husband and I have had about how to prepare sons (and some will apply to daughters), and I’m hoping many of you will lend your thoughts and advice as well (especially if you have married children!)

• Paint the picture. We start early by talking  about the concept of keeping one’s self for marriage.  Nothing heavy, but even as early as 9 or 10 we are painting the picture of giving all of one’s self to a spouse.  It is quite a natural thought when discussed regularly, and the idea of recreational dating becomes absurd.
• Vision. As sons get older, they need parents to lay out a vision of what is expected.

Financial responsibility is something we talk about.  Sons need to enter marriage not only financially secure (i.e. at the least, providing income, preferably a nice savings and I would suggest NO debt), but also with a solid grasp of wise financial behavior.  If parents helped their children with just this one thing, it would save many a heartaches in their marriages.

Spiritual leadership. A man doesn’t just become a spiritual leader once he is wed.

(I’d kindly ask that those who hold an egalitarian view of marriage save your comments.  I know the arguments, the Greek definitions, the interpretations–I’ve heard every angle, so you don’t have to spend your time trying to convince me.  I also know the Bible never uses the term “spiritual leader”.   If it makes you feel better, believing a husband should be a spiritual leader DOES NOT  imply that a wife can’t be equally knowledgeable and spiritually wise.)

Helping sons take responsibility in this area is something easily overlooked, but vitally important.  Of course talking about it is one way to emphasize its importance, but  getting him in the habit of leading will make the transition natural.  Having him read Scripture to the family as soon as he is old enough to read is one way.  As he matures later on, Dad may have him prepare and lead the family in short devotions from time to time.  I think it’s important to challenge both our sons and daughters about spiritual matters by asking them questions and pressing them to “rightly divide the word of truth”.

Honor. Believing that husbands should honor their wives, we expect our sons to “practice” by honoring their mother and sisters. This is an area where I think Dad especially needs to hold the line and require it. I try to remind my boys to let the girls get out of the van first, and I try to make them alert to helping them carry things, opening doors, etc.  You know, all those things that now offend many women.  Chivalry is still encouraged at our house.

Example. I’m guessing the most important thing parents can do for their children in general, is to model the behavior they wish to teach.  Nothing cuts deeper into my soul than those words, because I fail SO often.  And yet I am reminded that “more is caught than taught”.

I’m eager to hear some of your thoughts on this…like everything else with raising children, I think it’s about being deliberate.  Thinking ahead and asking the question…”what kind of husband do we want him to be?”  And then gearing your thoughts and actions toward preparing him to be that husband.

Dating, Courtship, Marriage

Justin & Melissa

Whenever I bring up a topic, it’s invariably difficult to know whether to preface it with basic explanations for those unfamiliar with it, or to jump into the nuts and bolts for others.

With courtship, it seems there are so many misunderstandings about it, even among those who have “seen” it or are somewhat familiar.  I think it needs to be restated…courtship is not a magical formula, or a fool-proof method.

It’s really no method at all, but an attempt by those who recognize the danger and unbiblical nature of recreational dating to find a more sensible approach to marriage.

So before we talk about the practical side of it, I wanted to post some links I think many will find helpful and informative.

(If you’ve been reading for a while, these articles are probably a repeat for you…my apologies

Beautiful courtship stories of two of our friends:

A Story That Must Be Told

Happily Ever After

Courtship explained:

It’s Not Really About Kissing

Courtship Gaining Popularity

No Dating?  And What is Courtship?

More Problems With Dating

A Personal Note:  Final Thoughts on Dating & Courtship–my story

Courtship Story: Quinton & Allison

I will likely be linking randomly to Seasons of Courtship throughout this discussion.  They have some great, inspirational and practical information that I think families will find very helpful. 

One of the most helpful things to us has been watching and hearing about other families who have walked through the courtship process.  It’s always helpful to glean from what has been beneficial and what has not as we think about how it will play out in our own families.

The following is one such story…there are so many, and I will post several of them throughout this series to give you encouragement and ideas.

“…I’d always wondered just what being grilled by a prospective father-in-law might be like.  The experience actually turned out to be rather enjoyable.  We had some very late nights where it seemed like nobody wanted to break up the party!  We discussed my purpose in life, my strengths and weaknesses, and most of all, why I wanted to marry Allison!

On October 4, Dana informed Allison of my interest.  Then…I waited.  And waited.  After a nail-biting week, she finally replied that she was willing to get to know me….”

The rest of the story…The courtship story of Quinton and Allison

I AM in Love

A while back I got an email asking me to talk a little about how to prepare sons for marriage using the courtship model.   We certainly have no experience yet, but we are striving to prepare our children’s hearts to think biblically about marriage, and to preserve themselves for the one God has for them.

Of course there must be the disclaimer: the word “courtship” means  different things to different people.  It really isn’t a definitive word.  But for lack of a better one, I’m using it to refer to a more biblical approach to marriage–the opposite of “recreational dating”.

Every family who practices courtship looks different, perhaps feels differently and has different ideas of how it is to be played out.  Still, many of us (and more all the time) agree that the current system of finding a spouse is having horrible results, both during the dating time and in the marriage itself.

So, the next few days will center around the ideas behind a different approach to marriage.  No rules about how it’s done per se, but some things to think about.  (By the way, I feel strongly that the father is to be the primary facilitator in this process, so I would encourage you to let him read these posts as well

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Meet the Wallers. I met the Wallers 3 years ago.  They came to our home and spoke to a group about their ministry in Israel.  The Wallers are a unique family in every way.  You know that just by looking at them.  Even to the most conservative, they are an intriguing family.

Years ago, they left a very “normal”, fast-paced, corporate life and moved out into the country to “live off the grid”.  They go back and forth between the states and Israel, where the heart of their ministry lies.

I’ve never met anyone like them before.  I’ve never seen such joy, absolute freedom, contentment, honesty, passion and love for every person they meet all wrapped up in one family.  You can’t meet them and not be affected.  Christ’s love oozes out of them.

This is a sneak peak of a documentary about their first son’s betrothal and marriage  (they don’t practice courtship, but a model very closely defined by the Hebraic tradition.)  I thought it would be fun to see something so uniquely wonderful.

I AM in Love

For those interested, here is a brief film on the Waller’s Journey Home…